What is Local Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

Prefer to listen to this podcast? Click play to begin.

Based on ten years of experience optimizing local business websites, here are crucial lessons for achieving successful local search engine optimization (SEO). Key takeaways include understanding that local SEO is fundamentally different from general SEO, avoiding the trap of trying to rank for an entire large city, and prioritizing realistic, less competitive keywords initially. The source emphasizes focusing on dominating your immediate local area before expanding, creating locally relevant content instead of generic blog posts, and avoiding inefficient duplicate content for service area pages. Finally, the importance of a mobile-first website, sufficient content on the homepage, dedicated pages for each service, avoiding scammy SEO tactics, and maintaining an ongoing SEO effort are highlighted as vital for achieving and sustaining strong local rankings and generating leads.

Key Learnings from Optimizing 500 Local Business Websites

Summary: This document summarizes the crucial lessons learned over ten years of helping local businesses improve their search engine rankings on Google. The author highlights common mistakes, effective strategies, and the fundamental differences between general SEO and local SEO. Key takeaways emphasize the importance of understanding Google's local algorithm, focusing on specific service areas, targeting relevant keywords, prioritizing mobile optimization, creating authentic content, and maintaining an ongoing SEO effort.
​
Main Themes and Important Ideas/Facts:
1. Local SEO is Fundamentally Different from General SEO:

• Core Idea: Local SEO is not simply a scaled-down version of general SEO. Google uses a distinct algorithm for local search results with its own specific ranking factors.
• Important Fact: The author initially struggled by applying general SEO principles to local businesses and saw minimal results until they understood the nuances of local search.
• Quote: "lesson number one local SEO isn't just regular SEO but smaller it's a whole different beast if you're hiring someone make sure they know local SEO not just SEO in general otherwise you're probably wasting your time and if you're doing it yourself make sure you really understand how local search works because winging it won't get you very far"

2. Focus on Specific Local Areas, Not Entire Large Cities:

• Core Idea: While ranking in a massive city might seem appealing, it's often a logistical and impractical strategy for local service businesses. Targeting smaller, specific neighborhoods is more efficient and profitable.
• Important Fact: The author's initial success ranking an electrician across all of London resulted in logistical challenges and burnout for the client. Focusing on smaller areas led to increased efficiency and profitability.
• Quote: "lesson number two is don't chase rankings for massive cities especially ones as big as London it might sound great on paper but in reality it's a logistical nightmare instead focus on smaller local areas or neighborhoods you'll spend less time stuck in traffic and more time actually getting paid"

3. Target Relevant, Lower-Competition Keywords, Especially for New Sites:

• Core Idea: Attempting to rank for broad, highly competitive keywords with a new website that lacks authority is a waste of time and effort. Focusing on more specific, less competitive terms yields quicker wins and helps build authority.
• Important Fact: The author's early attempt to rank a new plumbing site for "plumber Boston" failed completely due to the site's lack of authority. Shifting to a more specific term like "hot water heater repair Boston" brought in rankings and leads.
• Quote: "lesson three is this don't waste your time going after ultra competitive keywords if your site's not ready if your website is brand new or still growing focus on more specific lower competition terms first they'll bring in quicker wins help build your authority and set you up to go after those bigger keywords later when your site's strong enough to compete"
• Tool Recommendation: SEMrush is recommended for keyword research, competitive analysis, and identifying relevant terms.

4. Build Local Authority Before Attempting to Rank in Multiple Locations:

• Core Idea: Businesses should prioritize ranking strongly in their immediate operating area before trying to expand their reach to other towns or cities.
• Important Fact: Many businesses trying to rank in multiple locations were not even ranking in their own neighborhood. Focusing 100% on dominating the local area made expansion much easier and more effective.
• Quote: "lesson number four is don't try to rank everywhere if you're not even ranking at home start local build your authority in your immediate area first once that's solid growing your visibility in surrounding areas becomes a whole lot smoother and way more effective"

5. Create Locally Relevant Content Instead of Generic Blog Posts:

• Core Idea: Generic blog content is unlikely to rank and drive local traffic. Focusing on content specifically tied to the local area attracts the right audience and builds local authority.
• Important Fact: The author initially wrote generic blog articles that failed to rank. Shifting to locally focused content (e.g., "dog friendly restaurants in your city") led to rankings and local leads.
• Quote: "lesson number five is stop writing generic blog posts no one's going to a plumber's website to learn DIY plumbing tips that's what YouTube is for instead focus on locally relevant content local focused blogs help you show up in front of the right audience build authority in your area and actually drive useful traffic to your site"

6. Avoid Cookie-Cutter City Pages with Duplicate Content:

• Core Idea: Creating numerous city pages with near-identical content is a "cookie-cutter" tactic that Google penalizes. It's more effective to create a smaller number of high-quality, unique pages for priority locations.
• Important Fact: The author encountered a client with almost 100 identical city pages that weren't ranking or even indexed due to duplicate content. Focusing on building detailed, unique pages for a few key locations brought organic rankings and leads.
• Quote: "lesson number six don't fall for cookie cutter tactics if you're a service area business you can't expect to rank in every city you're not physically located in especially with thin duplicate content instead start small pick your five 10 most important locations create one highquality unique page for each make it valuable make it real then scale gradually so each new page actually helps your site instead of dragging it down"

7. Mobile Optimization is Crucial for Local Businesses:

• Core Idea: The majority of local customers access websites from their mobile devices. Websites must be fast, easy to navigate on small screens, and have clear calls to action to convert mobile visitors.
• Important Fact: The author noticed a shift in visitor trends towards mobile but poor lead generation from mobile users due to poorly optimized sites. Prioritizing mobile optimization after Google's 2016 update significantly improved site performance and leads.
• Quote: "lesson number seven is mobile matters more than ever if you're running a local business chances are most of your customers are going to visit your website from their phone not a laptop so don't make mobile an afterthought make sure your site loads fast looks great on a small screen has clear call to actions right up top and makes it super easy for people to contact you because if your site doesn't work well on mobile people won't stick around and Google won't either"

8. Don't Be Afraid of Long Homepages with Relevant Content:

• Core Idea: While minimalism might seem appealing, a homepage with sufficient relevant content is essential for providing information to visitors and helping Google understand the site's purpose.
• Important Fact: Early client sites with minimal homepages ranked poorly and had low engagement. Expanding the homepage with answers to common questions, service details, and social proof led to improved rankings, visitor engagement, and conversions.
• Quote: "lesson number eight is don't be afraid of long homepages less isn't always best if someone's searching for your service they're looking for information not minimalism and Google feeds of content use your homepage to answer common questions explain what you do show social proof and guide people clearly to the next step the more useful your homepage is the more likely people are to stay trust you and convert and the more keywords it will rank for on Google"

9. One-Page Websites Are Ineffective for Ranking Multiple Services:

• Core Idea: While simple, a one-page website limits the ability to rank for diverse services as it confuses Google's algorithm. Dedicated pages for each key service are necessary for clear targeting and better rankings.
• Important Fact: A client with a one-page website trying to rank for all their services (boiler repairs, bathroom installations, etc.) failed to rank effectively. Building a multi-page site with individual service pages led to improved rankings and clients.
• Quote: "lesson number nine is onepage websites don't work for SEO forget the idea of using a one-page website if you're trying to rank for multiple services it might look simple but it completely limits your ability to rank if you want Google to understand what you do and send traffic your way give each key service its own page more clarity equals better rankings equals more clients"

10. There is No "Silver Bullet" or Quick Fix for SEO:

• Core Idea: Be wary of promises of fast, cheap SEO results. Effective SEO requires strategy, knowledge, and consistent effort, not outdated tactics like mass directory submissions.
• Important Fact: The author highlights experiences with "cheap SEO" companies using outdated tactics that provide no real results and can even lead to loss of control over online assets.
• Quote: "lesson number 10 is there is no silver bullet if someone promises fast SEO result for dirt cheap it's a scam period real SEO isn't about spamming directories or flipping a magic switch it takes strategy real knowledge and consistent effort all the time and here is the worst part these cheap SEO companies often control your website and listings so when you stop paying they lock you out so remember this cheap SEO isn't cheap it just costs more later in loss time lost traffic and fixing all the mess they left behind"

11. SEO is an Ongoing Process, Not a One-Time Task:

• Core Idea: Website optimization and SEO efforts are not a "set it and forget it" project. Google's algorithm changes, competitors evolve, and consistent updates and maintenance are necessary to maintain rankings.
• Important Fact: The author experienced a client's site rankings drop after neglecting ongoing SEO efforts. Consistent proactive work is crucial for long-term success.
• Quote: "lesson number 11 is don't rest on your laurels don't get comfortable just because your site is doing well right now google's algorithm changes your competitors evolve and if your site stays the same it falls behind think of your website like a living breathing thing it needs fresh content regular updates ongoing tweaks to keep it in shape it's called organic traffic for a reason if you don't feed it it dies so stay proactive and your site will keep working for you long after that initial launch"

12. Authenticity and Personality Build Trust and Improve Rankings:

• Core Idea: Using real photos, showcasing the team, sharing local work, and creating unique content makes a website more trustworthy and relatable to visitors. This authenticity also helps with search engine rankings.
• Important Fact: The author's experiment replacing stock photos with real images and personal details led to increased visitor trust, longer site duration, and improved rankings and leads.
• Quote: "lesson number 12 is this be real be personal be you your website is your chance to show people who you are and why they should trust you so stop hiding behind stock photos and generic text instead show your actual team share your story highlight local work you've done and use content only you can create when people connect with what they see they're more likely to reach out and when Google sees unique authentic content it ranks you higher because today authenticity isn't just a nice to have it's essential"

Key Considerations for Local Business SEO

Is local SEO the same as general SEO?

• No, local SEO is a completely different discipline from general SEO. Google uses a separate algorithm specifically for local search results with its own unique rules and factors. Understanding elements like Google Business Profiles, customer reviews, local citations, location-specific keywords, and local content is crucial for success in local search, and simply applying general SEO practices to a local business may not yield results.

Should I try to rank my local business in a massive city?

• Targeting rankings in extremely large cities, while seemingly appealing for broader reach, can be a logistical nightmare for a local business. It can lead to significant travel time and inefficiency. Instead of chasing rankings across an entire sprawling urban area, it's more effective and profitable to focus on smaller, specific local areas or neighborhoods closer to where the business operates.

How should a new local business website approach keyword targeting?

• For a brand new local business website with no established authority, targeting highly competitive, broad keywords is generally ineffective. Such sites lack the backlinks and history Google values. It's better to start with more specific, lower-competition keywords that are relevant to the business's services and location. Ranking for these niche terms can bring in quicker wins, build website authority, and pave the way for targeting bigger keywords later. Using tools like SEM Rush can help identify suitable keywords based on competition and your site's current strength.

If my business serves multiple locations, should I try to rank in all of them simultaneously?

• Trying to rank in multiple locations before establishing a strong presence in your primary service area is a common mistake. If your website isn't already ranking well in its immediate vicinity, it's highly unlikely to rank in surrounding areas. The recommended strategy is to focus entirely on dominating your local area first. Once you have a solid ranking foundation in your home base, expanding visibility into nearby neighborhoods becomes significantly easier and more effective.

Is writing generic blog posts a good strategy for local businesses?

• Writing generic blog posts on broad topics that don't have a local angle is often a waste of time and resources for local businesses. These posts compete with large, authoritative websites and rarely rank for relevant keywords, resulting in no traffic or leads. Instead, local businesses should focus on creating locally relevant content that is tied to their specific area. This type of content is more likely to rank, attract the right local audience, and drive useful traffic and leads.

How effective are city pages for service area businesses, and how should they be created?

• Creating city pages is a common strategy for service area businesses, but simply creating numerous pages with duplicated content and swapped city names is ineffective. Google recognizes and penalizes duplicate content. To be successful, city pages should be high-quality, unique, and provide real value for each specific location targeted. It's better to start with a limited number of high-priority locations and build detailed, distinct pages for each, gradually scaling up as your site's authority grows.

How important is mobile optimization for local business websites?

• Mobile optimization is crucial for local businesses because a significant and growing number of potential customers access websites from their phones. If a website is slow, difficult to navigate, or doesn't display correctly on a mobile device, visitors are likely to leave, negatively impacting leads and rankings. Google's mobile-first indexing means the mobile version of your site primarily determines your ranking. Prioritizing a fast, clean, and easy-to-use mobile experience with clear calls to action is essential for retaining visitors and improving search visibility.

Should local business homepages be minimal or contain more content?

• Contrary to the belief that less is always more, a minimal homepage with limited content is generally ineffective for local business SEO. Such pages often don't provide enough information to answer common questions or explain services, leading to confusion and high bounce rates. Furthermore, they lack the content density needed to rank for multiple relevant keywords. Expanding the homepage to include detailed information about services, answer FAQs, display testimonials and trust signals, and clearly guide visitors can significantly improve rankings, visitor engagement, and conversion rates.

Ready to rank higher and have more clients find you online? 
View our order page to learn more, and sign up today:

LOCAL SEO by Crawford Designs. Click to Learn More.